Holographic Wills: Lessons from Aretha Franklin’s Estate

In estate planning, trust and estate professionals are responsible for establishing and following legal documentation that ensures the deceased’s last wishes are honored and their descendants are provided for. One of the most complicated of these documents is the holographic will. Unlike formal wills, which are carefully drafted, witnessed, and notarized, holographic wills are handwritten by the testator and are often created under pressing or unusual circumstances. Understanding the validity and implications of these wills is crucial, especially with wills involving substantial estates.

What is a Holographic Will?

A holographic will is a handwritten document created and signed by the testator without the formalities typically required for wills, such as witness signatures or notarization. While common over a century ago, holographic wills are relatively rare today. However, they still hold legal weight in certain states, provided they meet specific criteria.

In the United States, 27 states recognize holographic wills, though the requirements vary. Some states demand that the entire will be in the testator’s handwriting, while others only require that the essential provisions, such as the distribution of property, be handwritten. A few states require that the holographic will be dated to be considered valid.

Legal Requirements and Recognition of Holographic Wills

For a holographic will to be legally binding, it must fulfill several requirements:

• Handwritten Content: Depending on a state’s laws, a holographic will must be entirely in the testator’s handwriting or at least have the material provisions in their handwriting.
• Intent: The document must indicate that it is intended to serve as a will.
• Clarity: It should clearly describe the property and identify the beneficiaries.
• Signature: The testator must sign the holographic will, with some states also requiring a date.

States such as Texas, Arizona, and California have laws that are relatively relaxed around holographic wills, allowing them to be admitted to probate if they meet the above criteria. However, in states like Florida, holographic wills are only recognized if they adhere to the formalities of a typed will, including being witnessed. This difference in legal treatment can lead to significant complications, as was the case with the estate of Aretha Franklin.

The Case of Aretha Franklin: A Cautionary Tale

When Aretha Franklin, known as the Queen of Soul, died in 2018, she left behind an estate valued at approximately $6 million. Instead of a smooth distribution of assets, her estate became the subject of a legal battle among her heirs. The dispute centered on two documents—a 2010 holographic will found in a locked cabinet and another from 2014 found in a notebook under a couch cushion.

The two wills laid out different instructions for how she wanted her Michigan home divided among her sons. Unsurprisingly, her sons could not agree on which document should prevail. Ultimately, a jury in Michigan ruled that the 2014 will was valid, mainly due to the state’s recognition criteria of holographic wills. This decision awarded her son, Kecalf Franklin, her $1.1 million home, the most valuable asset in her estate.

This high-profile case underscores the complexities and potential pitfalls of holographic wills. While they may offer a quick solution in emergency situations, the lack of formalities and the potential for multiple conflicting documents can lead to prolonged legal disputes, significant emotional distress, and unnecessary legal costs.

Clear Planning for a Secure Legacy

The uncertainty surrounding Aretha Franklin’s estate reminds us of the importance of precise estate planning, including the specification of heirs, their identities, and their share of assets. Holographic wills can open the door to disputes that can impact your client’s legacy and create rifts among their heirs. As trust and estate professionals, it’s critical to guide clients toward creating comprehensive, legally sound wills that leave no room for doubt or conflict.

For legal professionals with clients who need to establish heirship for probate purposes, HeirSearch offers unparalleled service and commitment, with a 97% success rate.

Contact us to learn more about our process and how we can support your needs.

Phone: +1 (800)-663-2255

This report is for informational purposes only and is intended only as a reference. HeirSearch does not endorse or recommend any of the products or services offered in the third-party articles or content contained within. We cannot guarantee the accuracy or effectiveness of the same and will not assume any liability related to the same. Additionally, nothing contained herein may be construed as legal advice. All offers are void where prohibited by law. Copyright ©International Genealogical Search Inc. All rights reserved.